TraxInSpace reviews for the song "Paninaro'95-98" by Sergeisergeievich


========================================

Reviewer: Anthrax 

Date of Review: 11/23/1998 9:33:00 AM 

Overall Impression: 6/10 

Review: An ok remix, with some exciting new features to the original,
but too much loops....

Creativity: 5/10 

Creativity Comment: Track the drums yourself, don't use finished
loops!

Artistic License: 6/10 

Artistic License Comment: Some new features to the song. 

Arrangement: 6/10 

Arrangement Comment: Quite average, not perfect. 

Sample Quality: 5/10 

Sample Quality Comment: Could have been better! 

Does It Work as a Piece of Music: Yes 

Does It Work as Music Comment: Some things could have been done
better, but it works...
   
========================================

Reviewer: Johnny Guitar 

Date of Review: 11/16/1998 10:18:00 AM 

Overall Impression: 7/10 

Review: This is fun to listen to!I never heard the original, but this
sounds good to me!Maby thers a little to much repetition of some
parts,some parts seem a little out of beat, but all in all this is a
good song!If ur a Pet Shop Boys fan,this is a "must have"!

Arrangement: 7/10 

Arrangement Comment: All parts fit and make an all rounded up piece... 

Sample Quality: 6/10 

Sample Quality Comment: Good,but i just hate when people use recorded
drum beats... plz,plz,plz,plz,plz make your own beat next time...
 
========================================


ModArchive review

http://www.modarchive.com/reviews/pan1naro.xm.rev.html

Quick Rating:  5.5

Classification:remix/techno

Musical Rating: OK/Novice

    This is a nicely done remix of a Pet Shop Boys tune, but it lacks 
a catch. The voice samples are cool, and the beat is nice, but you can 
hear all of that from the Pet Shop Boys themselves. The slow break is 
nicely done, but lacks good percussion. The mix is clean, but a little 
light for the most part. Overall, this is a cool remix, done well against 
the original tune, but isn't worth a permanent position on your hard drive. 

Technical Rating: Good/Amateur

    There's some really trippy effects played out in this track, 
consisting of pitch slides and key changes. It has a certain trip-hop 
element later in the track which adds a lot to the effect, and is about 
s clean as I've heard it done. The syncopation is really nice overall, 
as well. Overall, there should be a little more volume added to some 
smaller bits of the track, and some dropped from others. Not too bad a 
go at it, though. 
 
Reviewer: Azo